Paul Haggis Loses Appeal, as Court Finds Rape Is a Hate Crime

A New York court has denied an appeal from director Paul Haggis, holding that rape amounts to a gender-based hate crime.

Haggis had sought to dismiss part of a lawsuit filed against him in 2017, in which he was accused of violating New York City’s law against gender-based violence. His accuser, publicist Haleigh Breest, alleges that Haggis raped her at his apartment in New York in 2013.

Haggis’ attorneys had argued that Breest’s lawsuit failed to allege “animus” against women in general. But a four-justice panel of the First Judicial Department Appellate Division rejected that argument, finding that the rape accusation by itself is sufficient to show animus under the city ordinance.

“Rape and sexual assault are, by definition, actions taken against the victim without the victim’s consent,” Justice Peter Moulton wrote for the court. “Without consent, sexual acts such as those alleged in the complaint are a violation of the victim’s bodily autonomy and an expression of the perpetrator’s contempt for that autonomy. Coerced sexual activity is dehumanizing and fear-inducing. Malice or ill will based on gender is apparent from the alleged commission of the act itself.”

The ruling is a departure from other cases, including those involving Jeffrey Epstein, music producer Dr. Luke and Fox Business host Charles Payne, in which courts have held that a sexual assault claim by itself is not enough to allege a hate crime.

“This is a historic ruling that breathes new life into the New York City law against gender motivated violence,” Breest’s attorney Zoe Salzman said in a statement. “This decision paves the way for a jury to hold Paul Haggis accountable at trial.”

The ruling did contain a win for Haggis. Breest’s suit includes allegations from three anonymous women who claim that they were also sexually assaulted by Haggis. The appeals court granted Haggis’ motion to strike those claims, finding they were unnecessary to show gender-based animus. That leaves some uncertainty as to whether those claims could be raised in a trial.

Seth Zuckerman, one of Haggis’ attorneys, asked the trial judge, Robert Reed, for a status conference to address how to proceed. Salzman argued that nothing in the appeals court’s ruling prevents those witnesses from being called to testify.

The appellate ruling, issued on Thursday, upholds Reed’s ruling from August 2018, in which he denied Haggis’ motion to strike the gender-violence claim, finding there was a sufficient showing to put the matter to a jury. Three of the appellate justices — Moulton, Ellen Gesmer and Cynthia Kern — agreed that the rape allegation by itself was sufficient to claim gender-motivated violence. The fourth justice, Peter Tom, wrote a concurrence agreeing with the outcome, but differing with the majority’s reasoning.

Breest has also filed a separate claim for assault and battery under New York state law, which was not challenged before the appeals court.

The New York City Council passed the Victims of Gender-Motivated Violence Protection Law in 2000. The ordinance came in response to a U.S. Supreme Court decision striking down the portion of the federal Violence Against Women Act allowing victims to pursue civil claims against perpetrators in federal court. Local jurisdictions, including New York City, responded by creating their own civil remedies for gender-based violence.

There have been relatively few cases interpreting the New York statute in the years since.

In 2016, Judge Shirley Kornreich dismissed two claims filed against Dr. Luke — otherwise known as Lukasz Gottwald — by singer Kesha, who accused him of rape.

“Although Gottwald’s alleged actions were directed to Kesha, who is female, the (counterclaims) do not allege that Gottwald harbored animus toward women or was motivated by gender animus when he allegedly behaved violently toward Kesha,” Kornreich argued. “Every rape is not a gender-motivated hate crime.”

In 2018, U.S. District Judge William H. Pauley dismissed similar claims brought by Scottie Nell Hughes, a former Fox pundit who claimed she was raped by Payne.

“While the alleged rape in 2013, if true, is despicable and undoubtedly constitutes ‘discriminat[ion] on the basis of sex,’ such an act was not a ‘hate crime,'” Pauley ruled. “Hughes offers no specific allegations that Payne harbored or expressed any animosity toward women.”

New York Justice Edward Lehner also dismissed a gender-based violence claim against Epstein in 2008, in which the financier was accused of forcing an underage model to perform oral sex. The judge held that the complaint “fails to state any facts showing that Epstein’s alleged acts demonstrated any hostility based on gender.”

More Biz

  • Ariana Grande

    Ariana Grande to Perform at 2020 Grammy Awards

    Ariana Grande will perform at the 2020 Grammy Awards, the singer announced today on her social media accounts. While there has been no official confirmation yet from the Grammys, sources tell Variety that several performers will be making the announcements themselves before the Grammys’ traditional, multi-artist announcements are made. Billie Eilish kicked off the tactic [...]

  • A Man Walks Into the Cnn

    CNN Sets Record $76 Million Back Pay Settlement With National Labor Relations Board

    CNN has agreed to pay $76 million to settle a back pay case involving union workers that marks the largest “monetary remedy” in the 85-year history of National Labor Relations Board. The dispute began in 2003 when CNN fired a group of unionized subcontractors working as video technicians and in other technical and support roles. [...]

  • Harvey Weinstein protest

    Feminist Protesters Chant Outside Harvey Weinstein Trial: 'The Rapist Is You'

    An organized group of women performed a feminist anthem and dance in protest outside of Harvey Weinstein’s trial in New York late Friday morning, while the disgraced movie mogul was inside the courthouse for jury selection for his rape trial, which began earlier this week. Protesters outside the courthouse chanted in Spanish and English, “It’s [...]

  • Gwyneth Paltrow, Oprah Winfrey

    In Honor of Goop at Sea, a Rundown of Celeb-Fueled Cruises

    Gwyneth Paltrow’s company, Goop, is taking wellness to sea with Celebrity Cruises. In August, cruisers will be able to experience “goop at Sea” on board Celebrity’s Apex ship. Paltrow will be on deck, as well as a slew of Goop-approved “healers.” The ship will also be sailing through Spain, France and the Italian Riviera. In [...]

  • Alicia Keys Talks New Single, High-Quality

    Alicia Keys Talks New Single, Female Power, High-Quality Sound at Amazon CES Panel

    The impact of high-definition audio has been top of mind lately for Alicia Keys, who teased new music and talked about her experience with the technology during a panel overseen by Amazon Music at the Consumer Electronics Show (CES) on Wednesday (January 8) in Las Vegas. The 15-time Grammy winner was joined on the panel [...]


    SAG Headquarters Evacuated Again After New Threat

    UPDATE: The SAG-AFTRA offices in Los Angeles and New York have received an all-clear after a bomb threat was called in for the second time in three days. “Earlier this morning, we received a telephone threat targeting our Los Angeles and New York national offices. We notified law enforcement and evacuated the buildings. The police [...]

  • The Brothers Mankiewicz book cover and

    Harvey Weinstein Brought Her Book to His Rape Trial, Leaving Author Stunned

    Harvey Weinstein was spotted carrying a book on Tuesday during the first day of jury selection at his rape trial in Lower Manhattan. “The Brothers Mankiewicz” tells the stories of Herman and Joseph Mankiewicz, two icons of classic Hollywood who each struggled with their respective demons. Sydney Ladensohn Stern, the author, said she was stunned [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content